Broker Check

Roth Conversion Strategies

A step-by-step framework for turning tax-deferred savings into tax-free retirement income, planned around your brackets, your timeline, and the decisions that connect them.

McDonough Capital Management models multi-year conversions for pre-retirees, coordinated with your CPA and scoped to your advisory relationship.

Since 1999 Independent Orlando RIA
CFP® Certified Financial Planner Team
Southwest Orlando 6000 Turkey Lake Road, Suite 212
FINRA/SIPC Securities Through Osaic Wealth, Inc.

Pay Tax on the Seed, Not the Harvest

A Roth conversion moves money from a pre-tax account, such as a Traditional IRA, 401(k), or 403(b), into a Roth IRA. You pay ordinary income tax on the amount you convert today in exchange for tax-free growth and tax-free qualified withdrawals for the rest of your life, and for your beneficiaries after you.

The question is rarely whether to pay tax on a pre-tax account. It is when you pay it, at what rate, and who ultimately pays it. The years between the end of full-time work and the start of Required Minimum Distributions are often the lowest-income years of a planning lifetime, and they are where a deliberate conversion plan can do the most work.

Done carefully, a multi-year conversion plan can lower lifetime taxes, reduce future Required Minimum Distributions, limit exposure to Medicare premium surcharges, and leave heirs a more tax-efficient inheritance. Done without a plan, the same conversion can push income into a higher bracket, raise Medicare premiums two years later, and cost more than it saves. The difference is the modeling.

A Strategy, Not a One-Time Transaction

This page lays out how McDonough Capital Management approaches conversions as a framework: the window where conversions carry the most leverage, the specific tactics we weigh, and the questions we answer before recommending a single dollar of conversion. If you are an Orlando resident looking for the local picture first, our Roth conversion guidance for Orlando residents covers the basics, and our forward-looking tax planning shows how conversions sit inside a wider multi-year tax strategy.

Tactical Guide for Pre-Retirees

The Roth IRA Conversion Playbook

A clear, step-by-step framework for turning tax-deferred savings into tax-free retirement income, without overpaying the IRS along the way.

Download the Playbook Free. No obligation.

Why the Timing of a Conversion Matters

Four rules set by Congress and the IRS shape every conversion decision. Each one is a reason to plan conversions across several years rather than in a single large move.

Age 73

When Required Minimum Distributions Begin

Required Minimum Distributions from pre-tax accounts now start at age 73, rising to 75 in 2033. Converting before RMDs begin can shrink those future mandatory withdrawals and the taxable income they create.

SECURE 2.0 Act of 2022; IRS
10 Years

The Inherited Account Drawdown Window

Most non-spouse beneficiaries must empty an inherited pre-tax IRA within ten years, often during their own peak earning years. A Roth inherited on the same timeline is drawn down tax-free, which is why conversions are a legacy decision as much as a retirement one.

SECURE Act of 2019; IRS Publication 590-B
37%

Top Federal Marginal Rate

The highest federal income tax bracket for 2026. A conversion is mathematically favorable when the rate you pay to convert today is lower than the rate you expect to pay later, which is the heart of the decision we model.

IRS, 2026 Inflation-Adjusted Tax Brackets
2 Years

The Medicare Premium Lookback

Medicare Part B and Part D premiums in any year are based on your income from two years earlier. A conversion at 63 can raise premiums at 65, so the surcharge timeline has to be built into the plan, not discovered after the fact.

Medicare, CMS; Social Security Administration

Figures are current as of the sources cited and are subject to change. This is not tax or legal advice. Please consult a qualified tax or legal professional regarding your circumstances.

Roth Conversion Planning

Five Conversion Strategies We Weigh

No single approach fits every household. We look at each strategy in the context of your tax brackets, income timeline, Medicare considerations, charitable goals, and broader retirement plan before discussing whether a conversion may fit.

01

Bracket-Topping Conversions

Convert just enough each year to fill your current marginal bracket without spilling into the next. This approach can be useful during years when taxable income is temporarily lower.

02

Medicare-Aware Conversions

Look beyond tax brackets and account for Medicare income thresholds as well. A conversion can affect future Medicare premiums, so the amount and timing both matter.

03

Down-Market Conversions

Consider converting assets after a market decline, when account values may be lower. Any later recovery then occurs inside the Roth, where qualified withdrawals can be tax-free.

04

Charitable-Offset Conversions

Coordinate conversion planning with charitable giving strategies when appropriate. The goal is to look at both decisions together rather than treating taxes and giving as separate conversations.

05

Survivor-Bracket Conversions

Consider whether conversions during joint-filing years may help address the narrower tax brackets a surviving spouse could face later when filing as a single taxpayer.

The Bigger Picture

Mapping Your Conversion Window

For many pre-retirees, the years between leaving full-time work and beginning required minimum distributions can create a useful planning window. Income may be lower during this period, making it worth modeling whether partial Roth conversions fit the broader retirement strategy.

Full-Time Work Ends Income picture begins to change
Potential Conversion Window Evaluate taxes, Medicare, and cash flow
RMD Years Begin Taxable distributions become part of the plan
Why Work With Us

Meet The Advisors Behind Your Conversion Plan

An advisor relationship is only as good as the people in it. Ours is a small, tenured team, and the same advisors who model your conversion plan are the ones you call with a question.

McDonough Capital Management has been an independent Registered Investment Adviser since 1999, operating from Turkey Lake Road in Southwest Orlando. Ed McDonough started in this business in 1987. Camie Nguyen has been with the firm since 2006.

  • Independent Since 1999

    The firm was established as a Registered Investment Adviser in Orlando in 1999. Independence means advisory recommendations are made in your best interest rather than to satisfy a product quota.

  • CERTIFIED FINANCIAL PLANNER™ Professionals

    Both Ed and Shannon McDonough hold the CFP® certification. Ed also holds the Series 65 along with Life, Health, and Variable insurance licenses.

  • Conversions Coordinated With Your CPA

    Conversion timing is modeled across tax years and planned alongside your tax preparer, so the year's income, deductions, and surcharge thresholds are accounted for before you convert.

  • Coordinated, Not Fragmented

    Investments, retirement income, tax strategy, and estate coordination are managed together by a team that shares one office and one plan for each client.

Edward A. McDonough, BSME, MBA, CFP

Edward A. McDonough, BSME, MBA, CFP®

Founder / Chief Investment Officer

Working with clients and investments since 1987 and founder of the firm in 1999. A Lehigh University engineering graduate with an MBA in Finance, he focuses on helping clients accumulate and preserve wealth with attention to risk tolerance and tax efficiency. Holds the Series 65 and Life, Health, and Variable insurance licenses.

Shannon McDonough, MBA, CFP

Shannon McDonough, MBA, CFP®

Wealth Advisor

Leads day to day client planning, specializing in equity compensation plans, forward-looking tax strategies, and retirement income plans. Crummer Graduate School MBA, with CFP®, SIE, and Series 65, 7, and 63 registrations.

Camie Nguyen

Camie Nguyen

Investment Advisor / Senior Operating Officer

More than 27 years of investment, research, compliance, and accounting experience, with the firm since 2006. Leads portfolio trading and compliance, holds a Series 65, and graduated from Portland State University with degrees in Accounting and Finance. Not registered with Osaic Wealth.

Samantha Mosca

Samantha Mosca

Operations & Client Relations

Focuses on client engagement, relationship management, and resolving operational questions. Earned a Bachelor of Business Administration from the University of Central Florida.

Areas We Serve

Our office in Southwest Orlando is minutes from Dr. Phillips and the Bay Hill corridor. We meet clients face to face here and work with households throughout the greater Orlando metro, and nationally through virtual meetings.

  • Orlando
  • Winter Park
  • Windermere
  • Dr. Phillips
  • Lake Nona
  • Winter Garden
  • Maitland
  • Apopka
  • Altamonte Springs
  • Celebration
  • Oviedo
  • Kissimmee

McDonough Capital Management
6000 Turkey Lake Road, Suite 212
Orlando, FL 32819

407-248-9647 · Toll-Free: 800-741-0380 · mcm@mcdonoughcapital.com

Model Your Conversion Plan

If you want a clear, multi-year read on whether converting makes sense for your brackets, your Medicare timeline, and your legacy goals, we would welcome a conversation. We will walk through your situation and coordinate with your CPA.

6000 Turkey Lake Road, Suite 212, Orlando, FL 32819

Prefer to talk now? Call 407-248-9647

Frequently Asked Questions

Clear answers about how Roth conversion strategies work and when they tend to make sense.

When is the best time to do a Roth conversion?

For many households the highest-leverage years fall between the end of full-time work and the start of Required Minimum Distributions at age 73, when income is often at its lowest. Early-retirement years, a gap between jobs, or a down market can each open a window to convert at a lower rate. The right timing depends on your projected income, so it is a modeling question rather than a fixed age.

How does the five-year rule affect a conversion?

Each amount you convert starts its own five-year clock before the converted earnings can be withdrawn tax and penalty free if you are under 59 and a half. A separate five-year clock applies to the Roth account itself for tax-free earnings. Because the clocks are separate, the sequence and timing of conversions matter, which is one reason a multi-year plan is worth building in advance.

Should I pay the conversion tax from the IRA or from other accounts?

Paying the conversion tax from a taxable account rather than from the IRA itself generally lets more of your money keep compounding inside the Roth, and it avoids using converted dollars to cover the bill. Whether you have the outside liquidity to do that is one of the first things we check, because it often decides how large a conversion makes sense in a given year.

How can a conversion affect my Medicare premiums?

Medicare Part B and Part D premiums are based on your income from two years earlier, and they step up at set income thresholds. A conversion that pushes income over a threshold can raise premiums two years later. Planning conversions to the top of an income tier rather than past it is a common way to capture the benefit without triggering an avoidable surcharge.

What is the pro-rata rule, and when does it apply?

If you hold any pre-tax IRA dollars, a conversion that includes after-tax contributions is taxed proportionally across all of your IRA balances rather than letting you convert only the after-tax portion. This matters most for backdoor conversions. We review your full IRA picture before converting so the tax result is the one you expect.

Can I reverse a Roth conversion if my situation changes?

No. Since 2018, conversions are irrevocable and can no longer be undone through a recharacterization. That is precisely why we model the tax result before you convert rather than after, and why we tend to convert in measured annual amounts instead of one large move.

Who tends to benefit most from a conversion strategy?

Conversions tend to help pre-retirees with meaningful pre-tax balances who expect lower income years before Required Minimum Distributions begin, married couples planning for the compressed brackets a surviving spouse would face, and families focused on leaving a more tax-efficient inheritance. Whether it fits you depends on your current and projected rates, which is what a Roth conversion consultation is for.

Roth Conversion Strategies

At McDonough Capital Management in Orlando, we believe smart tax planning goes hand-in-hand with thoughtful retirement planning. One strategy people often ask about is a Roth Conversion — what it is, how it might fit into your broader financial picture, and how it could play into the retirement future you’re working toward.

Roth Conversions have some real potential benefits for those thinking long term. But, like most financial decisions, they’re not one-size-fits-all, and the rules around them can feel a bit confusing until you walk through them with someone who gets it. That’s where working with a financial advisor familiar with Roth Conversion Rules can make all the difference — especially if you’re planning for retirement in Florida or just want to optimize your tax picture while you’re still earning. Click below to book a free consultation.

Book a Free Consultation
What Is a Roth Conversion?

What Is a Roth Conversion?

A Roth Conversion is simply the process of moving money from a traditional IRA, or certain other pretax retirement accounts, into a Roth IRA. When you convert, you pay income tax on the amount converted now — instead of later — with the goal that future withdrawals can be tax-free (subject to the IRS rules).

That’s key: you’re choosing to handle the tax bill today so you could have more flexibility down the road. But timing matters, and so do the amounts you convert in a given year.

Why Consider Roth Conversions?

There are a few reasons people consider Roth Conversions as part of their retirement strategy:

  • First, it can help manage your tax brackets. If you suspect your tax rate is lower today than it could be in the future — maybe you’ve just retired, or you’re between big income events — converting now might make sense.
  • Second, Roth accounts don’t require you to take required minimum distributions (RMDs) after age 73 — so your money can stay in the market longer if you don’t need it for living expenses.
  • And last, Roth assets can be a tax-diverse part of your retirement plan. Having flexibility can matter — especially if you’re watching tax policy or market swings.

But none of that means “always convert.” It means making the right moves for you, based on your income, long-term goals, and your overall IRA balance.

How Roth Conversion Rules Work

There are important mechanics behind Roth Conversions that every investor should understand:

  • Tax Implications: When you convert funds from a traditional IRA to a Roth IRA, you’ll recognize those converted amounts as ordinary income for tax purposes in the year of the conversion.
  • No Early Withdrawal Penalty (if rules are followed): Unlike taking cash out, converting doesn’t trigger the 10% early withdrawal penalty — even if you’re under age 59½ — because you’re moving between eligible retirement accounts.
  • Five-Year Rule: Each conversion you make has its own five-year clock for tax-free treatment at withdrawal. That’s separate from the original IRA timeline.

All that to say — Roth Conversion Limits and rules do matter. The IRS doesn’t put a hard cap on Roth Conversions like it does on annual IRA contributions, but the tax impact and timing can be meaningful. You don’t want surprises when April comes around.

What About Backdoor Roth IRA Moves?

What About Backdoor Roth IRA Moves?

For high-income earners in Orlando — where traditional Roth IRA contribution limits may be out of reach — Backdoor Roth IRA strategies can be worth exploring.

A Backdoor Roth IRA involves making a nondeductible contribution to a traditional IRA, then converting those funds to a Roth IRA. It’s a legal way for taxpayers above certain income thresholds to get money into a Roth account when direct contributions aren’t allowed.

But — and this is important — tax nuances can change how much benefit you get, especially if you have other traditional IRAs or tax-deferred accounts. That’s why one-on-one planning helps clarify whether this approach fits your situation.

Is a Roth Conversion Right for You?

Here’s the part where it gets personal.

A Roth Conversion strategy isn’t something you check off a list. It’s about looking at:

  • Your current income tax bracket
  • Expected future tax situations
  • How long you intend to hold and use your retirement assets
  • Whether you expect Social Security, pensions, or other taxable income in retirement

And yes, it can also play into estate planning for families who want to pass assets down more tax-efficiently.

In our experience working with Orlando-area clients, people appreciate having a tailored strategy that complements their retirement vision, not just a generic “tax move.” We’re here to help you think through the timing, the tax bill, and how a Roth Conversion could integrate with your broader financial roadmap.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the current Roth Conversion Limits?

Unlike Roth IRA contributions, Roth Conversion limits aren’t capped by income. You can convert any amount, but higher conversion amounts mean more taxable income in the year of conversion.

Will a Roth Conversion raise my taxes?

Yes, converting means recognizing ordinary income. The goal is to pay tax now so you may pay less tax over time, depending on your future income picture.

Can I undo a Roth Conversion?

The IRS used to allow “recharacterizations,” but that option is no longer available for most conversions under current tax law.

How does this affect my retirement plan?

A thoughtful Roth Conversion strategy can add flexibility to your retirement income plan, influence your tax scenarios in retirement, and potentially reduce required minimum distributions.

Work With an Advisor Who Understands Your Goals

Contact Us Today

If you’re in Orlando or Central Florida and thinking about Roth Conversions, it’s wise to talk through your situation with someone who sees the big picture — investment goals, tax planning, retirement planning, the whole financial maze.

Contact McDonough Capital Management to explore Roth Conversion planning and how it fits with your retirement strategy.